If the video embedded above is not viewable, you can see it at these other fine video sharing sites: YouTube, Yahoo, Metacafe, Revver and Viddler.

It’s our first ever Battle of the Cereals review where you get to learn about two cereals in one and we get to duke it out to see which cereal is superior!!!! That sounds like fun, but how was it actually?

One cereal wins by a landslide, let’s just put it that way.

Kellogg’s Chocolate Peanut Butter POPS

NYCWD thought that Kellogg’s Chocolate Peanut Butter POPS was tasty, easy to get into, and chock full of goodness! Poppy thought it was pretty tasteless and didn’t particularly care for it. We both notice it is a very chocolatey pop, with a hint of peanut butter. A 3/4 cup serving contains 120 calories, 3 grams of fat, 2 grams of protein, and 21 grams of carbohydrates. It offers 25% recommended daily value of Iron, Thiamin, Riboflavin, Niacin, Vitamin B6, Folic Acid, and Vitamin B12.

Taste: Cocoa-y with a hint of peanut butter
Box opening: Easy
Bag rippage: Hard to open, but no actual rippage
Bag slippage: None!
Sog factor: It didn’t really get the chance while we were filming. The outside sogs out, but the center doesn’t sog out for a very long time.
Allergy alert: Contains peanut, wheat, and soybean ingredients

NYCWD’s Cereal Wednesday Bowls:

Poppy’s Cereal Wednesday Bowls:

Market Basket Peanut Butter & Chocolate

Poppy thought that Market Basket Peanut Butter & Chocolate was only tasty during the very last bite, pretty nasty before that, and hard to get into. The vitamins compare perfectly to NYCWD’s cereal, but he gives it the big thumbs down. We both notice it’s the peanut butter that dominates the smaller two-puff variety. Each 3/4 cup serving contains 120 calories, 3 grams of fat, 2 grams of protein, and 23 grams of carbohydrates. It offers 25% recommended daily value of Iron, Thiamin, Riboflavin, Niacin, Vitamin B6, Folate, Vitamin B12, and Zinc.

Taste: Peanut buttery if you wait until you get to the center
Box opening: Easy
Bag rippage: Also difficult to open, but no ripping
Bag slippage: Complete slippage out of the box
Sog factor: It didn’t really get the chance while we were filming. The outside sogs out, but the center doesn’t sog out for a very long time. (Hmm, this sounds familiar…)
Allergy alert: Contains peanut and wheat ingredients

Poppy’s Cereal Wednesday Bowls:

NYCWD’s Cereal Wednesday Bowls:

And The Winner Is…

Kellogg’s Chocolate Peanut Butter POPS!!! Who’s surprised?

For more information about Market Basket PB&C please visit one of their stores.


For more information about Chocolate Peanut Butter POPS please visit the Kellogg’s website.

Please note that there is a recall notice for certain product codes of the Market Fresh PB&C. Check your box carefully to make sure yours does not fall in the range of the notice (ours did not!). Safe cereal eating!